Submersible and external pond pumps are both popular options for water gardens and ponds. They both serve the purpose of circulating water, but they have distinct advantages and disadvantages that should be considered when deciding which type of pump to use.
Submersible Pond Pumps
Submersible pond pumps are designed to be placed directly under the water, typically at the bottom of the pond. They are submerged and hidden from view, providing a more aesthetically pleasing appearance. Here are some advantages of submersible pond pumps:
- Ease of Installation: Submersible pond pumps are easy to install. You simply need to place the pump in the desired location and connect it to the power source. The simplicity of installation makes them a popular choice among DIY enthusiasts.
- Energy Efficiency: Submersible pond pumps are generally more energy efficient compared to external pumps. They operate under water, which helps to cool the motor, reducing energy consumption and increasing the lifespan of the pump.
- Aesthetic Appeal: As mentioned earlier, submersible pond pumps are hidden from view, resulting in a more appealing and natural look for the pond or water garden. The absence of visible pumps and pipes allows for a cleaner and more visually pleasing design.
- Protection from Harsh Weather: Since submersible pond pumps are placed under the water, they are less affected by extreme weather conditions. For example, during freezing temperatures, the water surrounding the pump acts as insulation, protecting it from potential damage caused by frost.
However, submersible pond pumps also have some disadvantages that should be taken into account:
- Maintenance: Submersible pumps can be more challenging to maintain compared to external pumps. Regular cleaning and inspection are needed to avoid clogging caused by debris and algae that can enter the water.
- Difficulty of Access: Since submersible pond pumps are located underwater, any repairs or maintenance work may require you to partially or fully drain the pond. This can be time-consuming and inconvenient.
- Higher Cost: Submersible pond pumps are generally more expensive compared to external pumps. The additional cost is due to their superior energy efficiency, design, and construction. However, the long-term energy savings can offset the initial investment.
External Pond Pumps
External pond pumps, also known as centrifugal pumps, are placed outside the water and draw water from the pond through an inlet hose or pipe. They have their advantages as well:
- Easy Access for Maintenance: External pond pumps are easily accessible for maintenance and repair. There is no need to drain the pond, and you can clean or service the pump without getting into the water.
- Lower Cost: External pond pumps are generally more affordable compared to submersible pumps. They have a simpler design and are easier to manufacture, resulting in lower costs.
- Simple Installation: Installation of external pond pumps is straightforward. You place the pump outside the pond, connect it to the necessary pipes or hoses, and you're good to go.
- Less Maintenance: External pond pumps are generally easier to maintain. They are less prone to clogging since they are located outside the water. This reduces the frequency of cleaning and inspection.
However, external pond pumps also have some disadvantages to consider:
- Visible Appearance: Unlike submersible pond pumps, external pumps are visible, and their presence can disrupt the natural beauty of the water garden or pond. The presence of pipes and hoses can also be unsightly.
- Noise: External pond pumps can generate more noise compared to submersible pumps. The motor and impeller, being outside the water, are less insulated, resulting in more audible noise.
- Weather Impact: External pumps are exposed to harsh weather conditions, including extreme temperatures. During winter, the pump may be susceptible to freezing, which can cause damage if not properly protected or insulated.
Conclusion
Both submersible and external pond pumps have their advantages and disadvantages. The decision on which type to use ultimately depends on individual preferences, specific needs, and the overall design of the water garden or pond. Consider factors such as aesthetic appeal, energy efficiency, ease of maintenance, and budget when making a choice. Whatever type of pond pump you choose, it is essential to ensure proper sizing and installation to achieve optimal performance and longevity.
Publication date: